Shot Analysis: Ratatouille – Lead & Follow

wile-e-coyote

The force and locomotion of the lower masses drive all the action in this marvelous Wile E. Coyote production drawing by Chuck Jones.

One of the fundamental attributes of high quality, naturally believable animation is the ability of the animator to execute fundamentally sound “lead and follow.” This alone can separate the average animator from the reputable.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NtYtbxAgabQ&feature=youtu.be

The nose knows! (and it leads too!) In this delicious little shot, animation director Michael Venturini demonstrates delicately placed execution of the “lead & follow” concept. From Pixar’s Ratatouille, directed by Brad Bird.

Understanding the concept of lead and follow means understanding the basics of forces. You need to ask: what came first? Where does it come from? And what are the ramifications of that initial exertion?

In most cases, the forces begin internally – in the form of intention – it defines the drive and purpose of the action in the first place. We normally call that motive. Unless that is clarified first, you can’t make the next move. In other words, notes legendary teacher and Nine Old Men member, Eric Larson:

“Action will be prompted by the character’s emotions and his physical capabilities.”

Let’s take a closer look at the above shot of Remy, to see where and how all these internal and external forces play out:

Rat1
Mmmmm! Here the senses beyond the rational or intellectual take over, as Remy’s sense for the delectable pulls his attention towards screen right.

Rat2

Moment of realization; eyes and brain catch on as olfactory sense becomes activated sense of purpose. This nice pause creates the break needed for the audience to read and relate.

Rat3

Here, the nose, head and left arm lead the action, reaching out towards the items of interest. Clear direction and thrust of forces is evident.

Rat4

As the eyes marvel and upper body settles (correctly on the right ‘third’ of the screen), the lower half catches up, following up the shift in weight and balance, allowing the moment to read nice and clear.

Rat5

The next bit of business occurs as the body stabilizes, and Remy dives in to grab the goods.

Rat6

As he heads back to screen left, you see that this time, his lifted right leg leads the action, while the upper body follows. The head drags behind as the point from his nose to the feet form a nice line of action indicating torque, turn and twist.

Excellent, yet seemingly unremarkable shots like this one from Ratatouille, are scattered throughout in well-animated features. They are often overlooked and go unnoticed because they are mere seconds long despite being so beautifully executed. Understanding forces is the key to believable action like momentum and follow thru.

In the words of Glen Keane:

“Allow the momentum of and already animated movement suggest the next drawing. Draw the leading edge of forces.”

https://youtu.be/Tz_bQLnYVgw

Animation of another rat, the villainous Ratigan from Walt Disney’s The Great Mouse Detective. This gorgeous pencil test by the masterful Glen Keane, shows how the forces drive one pose to the next, creating weight and personality as varying regions of the body lead and follow one another.

Therefore, when you get the chance to watch good animation in isolation, pause and re-watch it. Look for places of where and how concepts like lead and follow are being handled. Your respect for the artist and the art itself will grow, and so will your understanding and inspiration.

Shot Analysis: 101 Dalmations

101DalmationsPoster

There are certain films I watch periodically for knowledge, growth and inspiration. In live action, they include films like The Godfather, Lawrence of Arabia, 2001: A Space Odyssey, and Akira Kurasawa’s Ran. I never seem to get enough of those films because they are so epically crafted, rich in human emotion, and nearly flawless. I learn something new each time, and find myself in awe of the artistic mastery on display. It’s like experiencing a dream.

“I dream my painting and I paint my dream.” – Vincent Van Gogh

Animated films don’t carry nearly that kind of complexity, grandeur or critical acclaim. But I do have a special list of animated films that rank amongst the most magical. One of them is Walt Disney’s 1961 classic, 101 Dalmations. Both the story and animation are a charm. The designs are unique and timeless, and within its 103 minutes of run time lie some of the most original and appealing scenes in animation history. It’s a landmark film amongst Walt Disney’s bounty of animated productions.

But today, we’ll focus specifically on one scene from the movie animated by the magnificent Milt Kahl. It’s a clip that describes Roger and his dog Pongo anxiously awaiting the birth of puppies, like expectant fathers. The scene is short (more than half the shot is a series of small movements and holds) but loaded with personality, contrast and beauty.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XBkCK78GLhU

Let’s break down some of the key areas of the animation choreography:

RogerPongo_Setup

Set up

The initial setup is simple, clear and nicely balanced. A geometrically perfect triangle tells you exactly where to look. The line along Roger’s legs, back and arm, along with Pongo’s elongated neck, create a continuous line of travel for the viewer’s eyes. There is physical contact in the hands which pat Pongo’s head, as well as social-emotional contact created by the direct eye-to-eye connection.

RogerPongo_antic

Anticipation

In the first bit of significant action (anticipation), you see a strong coil-like build up of the bodies in nearly simultaneous action. The lines of action (depicted in blue) reverse. Compression occurs between the heads and shoulders, while areas like the hands, sweater, hair (red) and Pongo’s ears reveal shapes that contrast from their previous positions, either dragging, or expanding.

RogerPongo_Stretch

Action/Expression

In the action/expression phase, you can see that Kahl has taken advantage of the elasticity of animal anatomy to demonstrate extreme force and expression. The lines of action of the bodies now spring almost straight and upwards towards the screen, while elements of the arms, hands and jaws reflect drag (yellow), giving them weight and interest.

RogerPongo_Hangtime

Hang Time

The most visually impressive and kinetic action occurs in the hang time, where Pongo frantically pedals his paws and Roger’s arms open upwards and outwards. Again, there is beautiful line of action in the main body masses, excellent display of overlapping action and shapes that give the shot depth, and a wonderful, almost floral texture and sense of excitement in the movement.

RogerPongo_Arc

Follow thru

As the characters collide into each other, Kahl achieves another marvelous contrast from the previous phase of action. Here, you can see and feel the force of the bodies compress into each other, as the follow thru of elements like the ears, hair, tail, sleeves and paws give the action real heft and believability. The arcs are beautifully conceived, as each body part flows naturally from one position to the other. It’s most intelligently displayed in the action of Roger’s arms as they envelop his dog in circular motion.

RogerPongo_End

Final Pose

In the final part of the scene, you see that Roger and Pongo, who were originally united by muted concern and only the slightest of contact, are now in full embrace at the end. Their arms and legs intertwine and overlap, their bodies glue together as one, while their attention jointly focuses towards the sudden alarm off screen. The conclusion of the action culminates perfectly.

People often attribute Milt Kahl’s notoriety due to his marvelous skill as a draftsman but when you look at a shot like this, you witness more than just beautiful draftsmanship or even perfect execution of technical elements. You realize that it’s all elegantly preconceived with much deliberation, effort and sincerity that shows how true the animator is to the characters and their situation.

“… it’s not the draftsmanship. It’s the conception.” – Milt Kahl

This sensational clip of animation is less than five seconds long, yet its quality and appeal is timeless. It’s a stark wake up call to all those animators who complain of doing “short shots.” It’s not the size or complexity that matters, it’s what you do with it.